Deposit Issues
- A deposit is not required to make a contract enforceable
- A deposit is a sign of good faith
- All deposits are non-refundable
- A refundable deposit must be specified
- A deposit is a pre-liquated sum that both parties agree will be the minimum amount paid to the Seller in the event of default
- A deposit “herewith” is required with the Offer
- A deposit “upon acceptance” is due in 23 hours and 59 minutes
- A deposit “as otherwise provided” is due when specified
- A deposit not delivered does not void the contract
- A deposit not delivered in time places the Buyer in breach of contract
- The Seller, then has two choices, in response to the Buyer’s breach
- The Seller may ignore the breach and proceed with the contract
- The Seller may terminate the contract
- If the contract is terminated, there is a quick procedure available through the Courts to obtain Judgment for the deposit (the full minimum amount)
- In addition, the Seller may seek damages, should that amount exceed the deposit
- For the Seller, the deposit should be as high as possible
- For the Buyer, the deposit should be as low as possible
- As a rule of thumb, most Ontario transactions use a 5% deposit
- The maximum deposit for the sale of a business under the Bulk Sales Act would be 10%
- Deposits should be paid to a third party stakeholder
- Interest should accrue on the deposit, particularly if it should take years to determine the rightful payee
- The deposit should be held by a third party in trust who is insured like a Brokerage’s trust account or a Lawyer’s trust account
- A Seller does not require a mutual release from the first Buyer before proceeding to consider a second Offer
- A mutual release would provide too much power to the first Buyer in breach of contract
- A Seller may accept the second Offer without notification to the first Buyer
- The two Offers are not competing as defined by REBBA, 2002
- The Seller can sue the first Buyer for the deposit amount, even following acceptance of the second Offer
- The Seller may also sue the first Buyer for any deficiency after the second sale is completed, after giving credit for the deposit amount
- Deposit funds may only be released by a stakeholder in accordance with the terms of the trust specified in the agreement
- If no specific terms are specified, then the stakeholder may only release the funds with both parties’ consent or upon receipt of a Court Order.
Brian Madigan LL.B., Broker